It’s a conversation happening in minivans, living rooms, and community fields nationwide. And while both paths have their benefits, more experts — and more families — are swinging the pendulum back toward playing multiple sports. Athletes Untapped highlights what experts and pro athletes have to say about the matter.
The American Academy of Pediatrics strongly advises steering clear of early sport specialization — particularly before ages 14-15 — and emphasizes the importance of rest. A University of California, San Francisco study reinforces the benefits of playing multiple sports: Among NBA first-round draft picks, those who were multisport athletes in high school appeared in a greater percentage of games and were less likely to sustain major injuries than peers who specialized early. Likewise, the International Olympic Committee supports multisport participation as part of healthy youth athletic development. Their consensus guidelines recommend that children sample a variety of sports to foster well-rounded athleticism, reduce the risk of repetitive overuse injuries, and build resilience long-term.
Chipper Jones
MLB Hall of Famer Chipper Jones has been outspoken about the dangers of pushing kids into early specialization. He’s emphasized that playing multiple sports builds different disciplines, keeps kids healthier, and avoids burnout. Jones has even said publicly that his own kids will play a variety of sports, not just baseball, because he knows firsthand how sampling different games creates a more balanced and resilient athlete.
C.J. Stroud
Houston Texans quarterback C.J. Stroud has also voiced his support for multisport participation. He explained that different sports challenge the body and mind in unique ways, developing fluidity, coordination, and mobility that a single sport alone can’t provide. Stroud credits his own athletic versatility to playing more than one sport growing up, arguing it’s one of the best ways to prepare young athletes for long-term success.
All of that said, there’s no denying why some parents choose the one-sport route:
But these benefits often come with trade-offs.
Research continues to show that kids who play multiple sports tend to thrive longer, stay healthier, and enjoy the game more.
As parents and experts, we often look to research, medical advice, and statistics to guide our decisions about youth sports, and that knowledge is valuable. But equally important is listening to the child at the center of it all. Are they smiling when they step on the field, building friendships at practice, and growing more confident in themselves? Their joy, feedback, and enthusiasm can be the clearest signals of whether we’re on the right path. One way to support that is by giving kids a chance to try new sports with different coaches.
At the end of the day, if kids are having fun, learning, and thriving both on and off the court — that’s the real win.
Yes, specializing in one sport might feel like the fastest route to scholarships or stardom. But the evidence — and the lived experience of countless families and pro athletes — suggests otherwise, especially before high school.
The real win comes when kids are free to play multiple sports, discover what they love, and develop skills that last a lifetime.
This story was produced by Athletes Untapped and reviewed and distributed by Stacker.